/
A Supreme Court bench of Justices MM Sundresh and PB Varale suspended the life sentences of Bipinchand Joshi and Pradip Modhiya and granted bail, citing over 17 years in custody, while their appeal against the 2017 Bombay High Court judgment is pending.

The Supreme Court has suspended the life sentences of two men convicted in the Bilkis Bano case and granted them bail while their appeal against conviction is pending. The order, passed by a bench of Justice MM Sundresh and Justice Prasanna B Varale and dated 28 October, was reported on 16 November 2026. It covers Bipinchand Kanaiyalal Joshi and Pradip Ramanlal Modhiya, two of the 11 men whom the trial court found guilty and whose conviction the Bombay High Court confirmed in 2017.
The order is not an acquittal. It does not say the two men are innocent, and it does not reopen the finding of the courts below. It says only that, with the appeal still to be heard, they need not stay in prison in the meantime. The conditions of bail are to be set by the trial court.
The bench suspended the sentences of Joshi and Modhiya and granted them bail "on such terms and conditions as may be imposed by the concerned trial court". The court did not list the conditions itself. The appeal against their conviction will be heard "in due course", and no date for it has been given.
The two men were appealing against the Bombay High Court's judgment of 4 May 2017, which upheld their conviction and sentence under sections of the Indian Penal Code that include rioting, murder and rape. The case arises from a First Information Report registered at Godhra Town police station in Panchmahal district, Gujarat.
Senior Advocate Siddharth Luthra, appearing for the two men, told the court that they had been in custody for more than 17 years. He said one of them was not named in the FIR and was brought into the case nearly three years after the incident. He also told the bench that one of the appellants is severely handicapped.
Additional Solicitor General Raja Thakare opposed the plea, arguing that the trial court and the High Court had both examined the material on record and that the offences were serious. The bench was not persuaded by that opposition. It recorded that the appellants had been incarcerated for more than seventeen years, that one of them has a severe handicap, and that the appeal raises issues "both on fact and law" that will need to be decided.
Suspension of a sentence pending appeal is a recognised course in Indian criminal procedure. An appeal against a conviction can take years to be heard, and courts sometimes release a convict on bail during that time, weighing the length of custody already served, the likely delay and the person's condition against the gravity of the offence. The Supreme Court's reasons here follow that pattern: time served, a disability and an appeal that is yet to be decided.
The power to do this comes from the criminal procedure law, which lets an appellate court suspend the execution of a sentence and release the convict on bail while the appeal is pending. Three terms are easy to confuse. A suspension of sentence pauses the punishment but leaves the conviction in place. Bail is the release that follows, on conditions such as a bond, sureties, reporting to a police station or surrendering a passport. An acquittal is a finding that the conviction was wrong, and only the appeal can produce it. The bench has done the first two and has said nothing on the third.
The trial court's conditions will decide how the release works in practice. Courts commonly require a personal bond with sureties, bar the accused from contacting witnesses and ask them to stay within a district or report regularly. The Supreme Court left all of that to the court that tried the case, which sits in Maharashtra, because the trial was moved there.
The appeal of Joshi and Modhiya remains pending and will be heard later. Nothing in the order changes the position of the other convicts. The wider history of the case explains why the order drew attention.
The case goes back to the violence in Gujarat in 2002. After the Sabarmati Express was burned at Godhra on 27 February 2002, a mob attacked a group of people near Pannivel on 3 March 2002, and Bilkis Bano, then 21 and five months pregnant, was among the victims. Local police filed closure reports. The Supreme Court transferred the investigation to the Central Bureau of Investigation on 16 December 2003, the agency filed a chargesheet on 19 April 2004, and the trial was moved to Maharashtra. The trial court convicted 11 accused, and the Bombay High Court upheld those convictions in 2017.
In August 2022 the Gujarat government released all 11 convicts under its remission policy. On 8 January 2024 the Supreme Court set those remission orders aside, holding that Gujarat was not the appropriate government to decide remission because the trial had been conducted in Maharashtra, and it directed the convicts to surrender. They returned to prison.
Bilkis Bano has said she felt pain, shock and disbelief at the latest order. The order itself carries no statement from her side.
The 2024 judgment and this order answer different questions. The January 2024 judgment dealt with remission, the early release of convicts under a state policy, and held that Gujarat could not grant it. The present order deals with a pending appeal against the conviction itself and with whether two appellants should stay in custody while it waits. An appellant can ask the appellate court for bail on the ground that the appeal will take long. The order does not touch the remission ruling, and it does not suggest that any other convict will be treated the same way. Each appeal and each bail plea is decided on its own facts.
The next step is for the trial court to fix the bail conditions, after which the two men can be released. The Supreme Court will take up the appeal on a date to be listed. Readers who want the exact wording and the bail terms should read the order on the Supreme Court's website once the trial court's conditions are recorded, since the bench left them to that court.
About the Author
Staff Writer
Prateek Rawat is a contributor to Wirony. All articles published under this byline undergo editorial review and approval before publication, with any necessary corrections handled…
What did you think?
China's foreign ministry said on 16 November that Xi Jinping, Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin will hold their first face-to-face meeting this week in Shenzhen on world peace and strategic stability. Trump says nuclear arsenals, Iran and Ukraine are on his list.
Reyaansh Agarawal5 min
ASEAN leaders meeting in Manila on 15 November said Myanmar has not complied with the 2021 peace plan and kept its leader and foreign minister barred from summits until there is meaningful progress.
Subhash Gupta4 min
Punjab BJP chief Kewal Singh Dhillon named manifesto and chargesheet committees for the 2027 polls. Raghav Chadha and other ex-AAP Rajya Sabha MPs hold roles; Avinash Rai Khanna and Sunil Jakhar lead the panels.
Prateek Rawat5 min
Pakistan has confirmed that climate minister Musadik Masood Malik will attend the SCO Civilisational Dialogue Forum in New Delhi from November 20 to 22, the first Pakistani ministerial visit to India since May 2023.
Reyaansh Agarawal4 min
Education Minister Dharmendra Pradhan resigned in July 2026 after weeks of Cockroach protests over exam paper leaks. Protesters ended their sit-in after government promises, but thousands were detained in New Delhi on 14 November.
Reyaansh Agarawal5 min
Emmanuel Macron is in Cambodia for a state visit and the Francophonie summit, then flies to Malaysia on 16-17 November. His first official Malaysian visit is meant to formalise a strategic partnership.
Prateek Rawat5 min
The Interior Ministry counted 106,000 marchers across France on 14 November, the fifth weekend of protests over living costs, schools and police powers. Police made 219 arrests and used tear gas in five cities.
Reyaansh Agarawal5 min
Akhilesh Yadav said on 14 November that the Congress wants 181 of Uttar Pradesh's 403 Assembly seats in 2027. The SP chief did not accept the figure, said the INDIA bloc would stay united against the BJP and dismissed BSP tie-up talk.
Prateek Rawat5 min
The White House says Trump, Putin and Xi are expected to meet on 19 November on the sidelines of the APEC summit in Shenzhen. Arms control and Iran lead the agenda, while Ukraine is not expected to feature.
Reyaansh Agarawal2 min
Shashi Tharoor says 115 of 315 MEA-cleared Bharat Summit speakers were denied entry or lost visas. The MEA called visa decisions sovereign on 13 November, and Rahul Gandhi apologised to absent delegates.
Amita Sahani3 min
The US Supreme Court agreed on 13 November to hear the administration's appeal over Trump's proclamation declaring an invasion at the southern border and suspending asylum claims. The D.C. Circuit held he cannot deny asylum categorically. Argument is expected in spring, with a decision by June 2027.
Amita Sahani4 min
The Ministry of External Affairs said on 13 November that India wants a positive, constructive and forward-looking relationship with Bangladesh and will take up all issues through existing mechanisms. The fifth consular dialogue, proposed by Dhaka, will be held at a mutually convenient time.
Amita Sahani5 min