/
Italy's data protection authority, the Garante, has fined Meta Platforms Ireland €805 million over a Facebook Android feature that accessed photos and videos without specific consent. Meta has 60 days to change the workflow and may appeal.

Italy's data protection authority, the Garante, has fined Meta Platforms Ireland €805 million, about $887 million, over a Facebook feature on Android phones that reached into users' photos and videos without their specific consent. The decision came to light on Sunday 15 November.
The Garante found that the Facebook app on Android devices accessed photos, videos and the metadata attached to them without asking users in a specific or explicit way. The authority estimates that roughly 20 million Android users in Italy were affected. Alongside the penalty, it has ordered Meta to rework how the feature asks for permission and has given the company 60 days to do it.
Meta keeps the right to appeal. It has said the proceedings did not involve using personal content to train artificial intelligence models.
The decision centres on a function labelled "Get suggestions from gallery when browsing Facebook". As the regulator describes it, the tool let the Facebook app look through the photo gallery on a person's phone while that person was scrolling through the platform.
The Garante's objection is to the way permission was obtained. According to the authority, the app asked for a broad, generic permission that covered the application as a whole. It never put a separate question to users about whether it could open their gallery. The feature was also enabled by default, so people did not have to choose to turn it on.
That gap is the heart of the case. The Garante's position is that consent to handle personal material has to be specific and explicit. In its reading, a general approval given to an app at the outset does not amount to a clear answer about one particular use of a person's pictures and videos.
A phone gallery can hold a great deal of private material, and the decision reaches beyond the images themselves. It covers the associated metadata as well, which means the information that travels with each photo or clip fell within the regulator's concern.
The authority also weighed several factors in setting the size of the fine. It pointed to the scale of the practice, given the 20 million Android users in Italy it believes were affected. It noted that the violation was ongoing rather than a single lapse. It took into account a prior regulatory history involving Meta, dating to 2019. And it said Meta had not cooperated adequately during the investigation.
The fine is directed at Meta Platforms Ireland, the entity named in the decision, and the euro figure is the one the authority set. The dollar amount is an approximate conversion.
The financial penalty is only part of the ruling. The Garante has told Meta to alter the workflow that Italian users see, and the company has 60 days to put the changes in place.
Three requirements are laid out. Users must be asked for separate, explicit consent before the app can reach their gallery. The app must say plainly what the data will be used for. And people must be given instructions on how to switch the feature off.
In practical terms, that would replace a single broad permission with a dedicated request tied to the gallery, accompanied by an explanation written for ordinary users. The order is aimed at the screens people actually use, not only at the company's accounts.
The Garante's findings describe a feature that operated without that kind of dedicated request. The corrective steps it has set out mirror the gaps it identified: no separate consent, no clear statement of purpose, and no obvious way to opt out.
Meta has the right to appeal the decision. The company has maintained that the proceedings did not involve using people's personal content to train artificial intelligence models.
That statement draws a line around what the case was about. The Garante's findings concern how the Facebook app on Android obtained access to gallery content and whether users had given informed, specific consent. According to Meta's own account, the question of training AI systems on that material was not part of the proceedings.
The company has not, in the information available, challenged the Garante's description of the gallery feature itself. Its full response, including whether it will contest the ruling before a court or how it intends to carry out the regulator's order, is not set out.
The Garante is Italy's authority for data protection, and its decision addresses a feature that sat inside one of the most widely used apps on Android phones. Its reference to a 2019 matter shows that this was not the first time Meta had come to its attention, and the authority counted that history when it fixed the penalty.
The decision also shows how the regulator treats consent in practice. A permission requested at the level of the whole app was judged insufficient for access to one category of personal files, and a default setting that switched the function on was held against the company. Those two points, rather than any claim about what Meta did with the material afterwards, are what the ruling rests on, alongside the Garante's view of the scale of the practice and of Meta's conduct during the investigation.
For users in Italy, the practical outcome will depend on what Meta puts in front of them. If the company follows the order, Android users of Facebook should be asked separately before the app touches their gallery, told what the data is for and shown how to disable the feature.
The 60-day period set by the Garante is the next fixed step. Within it, Meta must introduce the separate consent request, the clear explanation of how gallery data is used and the instructions for turning the feature off. Any appeal would run on its own track, and the decision as described sets no date for one.
About the Author
Desk Editor
Subhash Gupta is a writer at Wirony, contributing articles that are reviewed and verified by the editorial team before publication. The publication prioritises accuracy, editorial…
What did you think?
Microsoft says Outlook, Teams, Copilot and other Microsoft 365 services are fully restored after an outage across at least 74 countries that lasted over 24 hours. It blames a network capacity upgrade, not a cyberattack.
Amita Sahani5 min
Grand Theft Auto VI launches on Thursday, 19 November, on PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X|S, at $80 standard and $100 for the Ultimate Edition. Preloading is under way, the game needs at least 210 GB, and no PC version is announced. Reports differ on preload dates and some figures.
Subhash Gupta4 min
Outlook, Teams and Copilot stayed disrupted into 13 November after Exchange Online servers failed health checks. Microsoft extended its email timeout to 48 hours so delayed mail is not bounced and reports phased recovery. Hospitals, airlines and governments were hit. It found no sign of an attack.
Amita Sahani4 min
President Volodymyr Zelensky said on 12 November that a speed cap of about 161 km/h on Starshield, the military version of Starlink, has returned and is hampering interception of Russian jet-powered drones. Musk says the US military decides; Washington has not accepted responsibility.
Subhash Gupta4 min
Google announced two new eighth-generation TPU systems on 9 November. TPU 8tx is for confidential inference, with up to 2x lower latency than TPU 8t, and TPU 8i Max doubles compute, SRAM and HBM bandwidth over TPU 8i. The post gives no prices, memory sizes or availability dates.
Prateek Rawat4 min
China's Foreign Ministry said on 9 November that the Chinese spy allegation linked to Nvidia's chief executive is unsubstantiated and a smear. Spokesperson Guo Jiakun gave one-line answers on a reported 600,000 Nvidia chips in Hong Kong and on US curbs. Nvidia's board has opened an inquiry.
Amita Sahani4 min
Nvidia's board announced on 8 November an independent investigation, overseen by independent directors and outside counsel, after reports that CEO Jensen Huang was the target of a foreign intelligence effort. It has no reason to believe security or secrets were compromised; Huang will cooperate.
Subhash Gupta4 min
Rockstar says GTA VI pre-loading starts at midnight on 10 November, two days before the 12 November date given at pre-order. The download is up to 212 GB, boxed copies reach shops on 12 November and the game launches on 19 November.
Prateek Rawat4 min
Canva said on 4 November that 1,271 people, 22% of its staff, will lose their jobs or change roles or locations. Leavers get at least six months' pay, a year of healthcare and US$10,000 start-up grants. Product, Growth and Platform merge.
Amita Sahani4 min
On the night of 1 November, Ukraine's Air Alert app sent false warnings of radiation and a nuclear attack; about three hours later Russia's Emergencies Ministry app sent a false nuclear alert to 33 regions. Zelensky told a US broadcaster Ukraine hacked the Russian app in reply. Moscow names none.
Prateek Rawat6 min
Binance says hackers the FBI links to North Korea took about $6.3 billion on 29 October after months of work: a tampered installer in June, a fake recruiter and coding test in September, and an internal AI tool on 20 October. About 98% of losses are replaced.
Prateek Rawat5 min
DeepSeek plans at least 160,000 Huawei Ascend 950DT chips at a roughly 1 GW Inner Mongolia site and reportedly aims to start pre-training V5 on them from late 2026, say unconfirmed reports. Arm shares fell about 14% in two sessions to 2 November after Intel's weak outlook.
Subhash Gupta5 min