/
Russia's deputy foreign minister said on 20 November that Ukraine joining NATO, even as 'quasi-membership', is unacceptable. Moscow is pressing the US to revive its 2021 draft treaties, while Jared Kushner says Russia is 'comfortable' with Article 5-like guarantees.

Russia's Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov said on Friday, 20 November 2026, that Ukraine's accession to NATO is "a completely unacceptable option" for Moscow, and that even a "quasi-membership" or any "creative solution" of that kind is not acceptable. Speaking at an event in St Petersburg, he said security guarantees for Ukraine could be discussed only once Kyiv acknowledges the "non-negotiable" nature of Russia's demand that it not join the alliance. His remarks cut across the account given the day before by US envoy Jared Kushner.
Ryabkov said Moscow is not opposed to dialogue but will not discuss Ukraine joining NATO. He said that he sees "little difference" between the European Union and NATO, and that all questions must be settled on the basis of ensuring Russia's security. He said Russia had decided to invite European representatives to Moscow and that arrangements were being studied, while Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said no dates had been fixed.
Kushner, speaking in Berlin on 19 November, had said that President Donald Trump was open to an "Article 5-like" security guarantee for Ukraine, a reference to NATO's mutual-defence clause, and that Moscow was "comfortable" with the idea. Ryabkov's statement rejects that reading. Both claims cannot be right, and no text of any guarantee has been published.
Russia is also pressing Washington to revive the demands it made in December 2021, as the US opens talks on the wider framework for security in Europe after the war. The Kremlin welcomed an American offer to discuss that framework. On 15 December 2021 Russia gave the United States two draft texts, which the Russian foreign ministry published two days later.
The draft treaty with the United States would have required the US to "prevent further eastward expansion" of NATO, to deny membership to former Soviet states and to bar US bases and military cooperation in those states. The draft agreement with NATO would have committed members to "refrain from any further enlargement, including the accession of Ukraine", barred forces from deploying beyond the lines held on 27 May 1997, and barred military activity in Ukraine, Eastern Europe, the South Caucasus and Central Asia.
NATO rejected the core demands at a council meeting on 12 January 2022, and US Deputy Secretary of State Wendy Sherman called them a "non-starter". NATO sent written proposals on 26 January. Russia cites that refusal as a reason for its full-scale invasion of Ukraine on 24 February 2022, a claim that Ukraine and its allies reject.
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| 15 December 2021 | Russia gives the US and NATO draft treaties |
| 12 January 2022 | NATO council rejects the core demands |
| 10 to 11 November 2026 | US, Russia and Ukraine hold talks in Abu Dhabi |
| 12 November | US envoys Witkoff and Kushner meet Putin in the Kremlin |
| 19 to 20 November | Kushner in Berlin; Ryabkov in St Petersburg |
US, Russian and Ukrainian delegations met in Abu Dhabi on 10 and 11 November. Russia's delegation head, Vladimir Medinsky, said European security was central and had to rest on the December 2021 proposals. The only announced outcome was a preliminary exchange of prisoners of war. Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner then met Vladimir Putin in the Kremlin on 12 November, where, according to Kremlin adviser Yuri Ushakov, Putin reminded them of the 2021 proposals and said he would give them "fresh considerations".
Putin met Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping in Shenzhen on 19 November, with no breakthrough on Ukraine. He has said Moscow invited a European delegation to state its position before it decides the date and format of any talks on Ukraine.
A joint statement from Germany, France, Britain and Ukraine in Berlin called for legally binding guarantees, US-led monitoring of a ceasefire, a European-led multinational force backed by the US, and a winter energy ceasefire. French President Emmanuel Macron urged reopening the question of Ukraine's NATO membership. Putin has warned that European troops sent to Ukraine would be legitimate targets. EU foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas said that a ceasefire must come before wider security talks, and German Chancellor Friedrich Merz suggested the United Arab Emirates as the venue for the next round.
Analysts quoted in the commentary on the talks, among them Tatiana Stanovaya and Mark Galeotti, call Russia's demands an opening bargaining position. A Polish research institute assesses that Washington agreed to discuss the architecture of European security but most likely rejected a rollback of NATO forces to the lines of 1997.
The question that decides everything is whether any form of guarantee for Ukraine will be acceptable to Moscow, and Ryabkov's answer on Friday was no for anything that looks like NATO membership. Kushner's claim that Russia is comfortable with Article 5-like guarantees rests on his own account of private talks. A report that Putin is ready to accept a NATO-like shield with a catch could not be read, and the catch it describes is not confirmed here. The Russian foreign ministry and NATO are the sources for the 2021 texts and the responses to them.
About the Author
Staff Writer
Prateek Rawat is a contributor to Wirony. All articles published under this byline undergo editorial review and approval before publication, with any necessary corrections handled…
What did you think?
Iran's Revolutionary Guards said on 21 November a new air defence system shot down a 58th US MQ-9 drone over the Strait of Hormuz; the US had not commented. A tanker was hit off Khasab, Oman. Foreign Minister Araghchi set seven conditions to reopen the strait and Trump said he wants a 'real deal'.
Amita Sahani5 min
Young people marched in cities from Italy to Germany, Austria and Britain on 20 November under the slogan 'Fight for our future, not their wars', over rents, living costs, schools and rearmament. Tens of thousands marched in Milan, about 1,000 in Berlin and several hundred in London.
Reyaansh Agarawal4 min
European and Ukrainian officials say the US wants a Ukraine-Russia peace deal by early January, before Democrats take control of Congress. Trump says Putin wants to end the war by diplomacy. Russia's deputy foreign minister calls any quasi-membership of NATO for Ukraine unacceptable.
Prateek Rawat4 min
A US federal judge in Manhattan on 20 November sentenced Indian national Nikhil Gupta to 235 months for plotting to hire a killer for Sikh separatist Gurpatwant Singh Pannun. Prosecutors had sought about 24 years. India denies involvement, and the Indian official named in the case is at large.
Amita Sahani5 min
President Donald Trump said on 19 and 20 November he will discuss new strikes on Iran after the start of the year and is not rushing. The Senate rejected a Democratic war-powers resolution 51 to 48, and a Pentagon official put the war's cost at $48.3 billion as of 13 November.
Reyaansh Agarawal4 min
Prime Minister Andy Burnham and EU leaders announced deals in Brussels on 20 November on food trade, linked carbon markets and a youth experience scheme. Britain puts the food deal at up to 5.1 billion pounds a year. University fees for EU students and electricity are unsettled.
Prateek Rawat4 min
Poland says two missiles and a jet-powered drone crashed on its territory on 20 November during a major Russian attack on Ukraine, including a Kh-101 cruise missile near Nowy Lipowiec. Prime Minister Donald Tusk called it a provocation. Zelenskyy said Russia fired over 400 drones and 110 missiles.
Amita Sahani4 min
Saudi Arabia says a Houthi attack on 19 November caused material damage to the 385-metre PIF tower, Riyadh's tallest building, with no injuries. The coalition says it intercepted missiles and destroyed a launch platform in Dhamar. Witnesses told AFP windows were blown out.
Reyaansh Agarawal4 min
Vladimir Putin said Russia will not negotiate after Ukraine's strikes on the Crimean bridge and will respond in a way 'much more painful' than the damage, per Interfax. Ukraine says Neptune missiles hit the rail section overnight on 19 November, the third strike in a week.
Prateek Rawat4 min
Iran's IRGC Navy said on 19 November that two supertankers with over four million barrels each hit mines in the Strait of Hormuz and are burning. There is no independent confirmation. The IEA calls the Hormuz crisis the largest energy-security threat it has seen.
Reyaansh Agarawal4 min
After more than 90 minutes in Shenzhen on 19 November, Trump, Xi and Putin issued a four-point statement: UN reform, nuclear risk talks, more oil supply and respect for leaders' immunity, with an ICC warning. It does not mention Ukraine.
Prateek Rawat4 min
The International Court of Justice ruled 9-6 on 19 November that Myanmar is responsible for genocide against the Rohingya in 2017, the first time it has held a state responsible. It ordered investigations, a safe return and reparations, with compensation to be set later.
Amita Sahani4 min