/
A Bombay High Court bench of Justices G S Kulkarni and Neela Gokhale on 18 November questioned the temporary clean-up of parts of Mumbai for Prince William and Catherine's visit, saying 'have a permanent show', and asked the state and civic bodies to apply the same standard for citizens.

The Bombay High Court has asked why Mumbai was cleaned up for the visit of Prince William and Catherine, Princess of Wales, while it stays dirty for its own citizens. A division bench of Justice G S Kulkarni and Justice Neela Gokhale made the remarks on Wednesday, 18 November 2026, while hearing a petition, according to WION. The bench said that such a clean-up must not be a "temporary show".
The reports do not name the petition or say what relief it sought, and the bench's remarks are observations and not orders.
The judges questioned the authorities' clean-up of parts of the city ahead of the royal couple's three-day visit, naming Ballard Estate, an area that the couple visited. "Instead of having this temporary show of two days, have a permanent show," the bench said, according to the report by WION.
It also asked: "You are going to be alive only when important personalities visit the city?" and said that the approach "may not be appropriate". Turning to the people who live in the city, it said: "You have to act for the common man who is the permanent resident of this city." The bench asked the Maharashtra government and the civic authorities to ensure that the standard they achieved for the visit applies to ordinary citizens as well.
Prince William and Catherine were in India from 16 to 18 November. In Mumbai they played gully cricket at Ballard Estate with Sachin Tendulkar, took an e-rickshaw ride, visited a craft school and attended the Earthshot Prize ceremony on 17 November. They met Maharashtra Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis, and ended the visit with a meeting with Prime Minister Narendra Modi in New Delhi on 18 November.
| Date | What the royal couple did |
|---|---|
| 16 November | Arrived in Mumbai; gully cricket at Ballard Estate |
| 17 November | Earthshot Prize ceremony; children's Earthshot awards |
| 18 November | Craft school and studio visits in Mumbai; meeting with PM Modi in Delhi |
State visits and high-profile events regularly lead to sudden repairs, repainting and clean-ups in the affected areas, and citizens often notice that the same effort is missing the rest of the year. The bench's remarks put that practice on the record and ask for the standard to be made permanent. The comments do not by themselves require the BMC to do anything.
The city's air and cleanliness are also in the news. On 19 November, smog was visible around the Eastern Freeway at Wadala in Mumbai, according to ETV Bharat, and the city's air quality index was 130, which is in the 'moderate' range.
The reports of the hearing do not include a reply from the BMC or the Maharashtra government. The bench asked for the same standards for citizens, but the reports do not say whether it set a deadline or listed the matter for a further hearing. The orders on the High Court's website will show what, if anything, was directed.
The royal couple's visit had a packed Mumbai programme. William and Catherine played gully cricket with Sachin Tendulkar at Ballard Estate on 16 November, took part in the Earthshot Prize ceremony at the Jio World Convention Centre on 17 November, and on 18 November visited the Chanakya School of Craft, a film studio and a maternity hospital before flying to Delhi. Large events of this kind require road closures, repairs and cleaning of the areas on the route, and local authorities usually carry them out in the days before.
In Mumbai, the BMC is the body responsible for cleaning and lighting the public streets, and it spends a large part of its budget on solid waste and roads. The High Court's question is therefore about how a body with that responsibility can reach a high standard within days for a visitor and not for residents, and whether the resources used for the visit show what it can do. The bench did not, in the reports seen, say that the clean-up was improper in itself, only that it should not be a one-off.
For residents, the bench's remarks give a basis to ask their local ward offices and the BMC for the same standard on their own streets. The court's observation, that the effort cannot depend on who is visiting, is also a reminder that complaints about garbage, potholes and street lighting can be taken to the civic body's grievance channels and, if they are not resolved, to the courts. The reports do not say whether the bench asked the BMC to publish a plan for permanent upkeep, and the next hearing will show whether it does.
The first thing to watch is the BMC's reply in court, and whether it explains the cost and the process of the clean-up carried out for the visit. The second is whether the court issues directions on the upkeep of public places after the next hearing. The third is whether the same effort is visible in the areas that residents use every day. Until then, the remarks are a statement of expectation from the bench and not a finding against any authority.
About the Author
Desk Editor
Subhash Gupta is a writer at Wirony, contributing articles that are reviewed and verified by the editorial team before publication. The publication prioritises accuracy, editorial…
What did you think?
President Donald Trump said on 19 and 20 November he will discuss new strikes on Iran after the start of the year and is not rushing. The Senate rejected a Democratic war-powers resolution 51 to 48, and a Pentagon official put the war's cost at $48.3 billion as of 13 November.
Reyaansh Agarawal4 min
The Supreme Court on 20 November dismissed Karnataka's appeal against a High Court ruling lifting the bike taxi ban. Justice Satish Chandra Sharma said regulation is better than a ban and that bike taxis already run in 25 states. Ola, Uber and Rapido can continue, subject to state rules.
Prateek Rawat4 min
Prime Minister Andy Burnham and EU leaders announced deals in Brussels on 20 November on food trade, linked carbon markets and a youth experience scheme. Britain puts the food deal at up to 5.1 billion pounds a year. University fees for EU students and electricity are unsettled.
Prateek Rawat4 min
The Supreme Court on 20 November stayed the Madras High Court judgment and allowed a limited team from the temple to light the Karthigai lamp at the Deepathoon on Thiruparankundram hill on 24 November, as a one-time measure. It decides no question of custom or title and sets strict conditions.
Amita Sahani4 min
Poland says two missiles and a jet-powered drone crashed on its territory on 20 November during a major Russian attack on Ukraine, including a Kh-101 cruise missile near Nowy Lipowiec. Prime Minister Donald Tusk called it a provocation. Zelenskyy said Russia fired over 400 drones and 110 missiles.
Amita Sahani4 min
A Supreme Court bench of Justices Vikram Nath and Aparesh Singh on 20 November dismissed two Tamil Nadu applications seeking release of about 11 TMC of Cauvery water by Karnataka. A third application was listed after a week at both states' request. The order had been reserved on 12 October.
Subhash Gupta4 min
Gangster Naseem Durrani, 37, was shot dead late on 19 November in an encounter near Sikandrabad in Bulandshahr by a joint team of Delhi Police Crime Branch and the Noida STF. Police say he was wanted for the 16 November killing of Sameer near Kapil Mishra's office and had more than 20 cases.
Reyaansh Agarawal5 min
Cyclone Akvan crossed the south Odisha and north Andhra Pradesh coasts near Gopalpur on 20 November with winds of 70 to 80 km/h and weakened into a deep depression. Odisha says no one has died, 3.7 lakh people were moved to shelters, and crop damage will be assessed later.
Reyaansh Agarawal5 min
Saudi Arabia says a Houthi attack on 19 November caused material damage to the 385-metre PIF tower, Riyadh's tallest building, with no injuries. The coalition says it intercepted missiles and destroyed a launch platform in Dhamar. Witnesses told AFP windows were blown out.
Reyaansh Agarawal4 min
Vladimir Putin said Russia will not negotiate after Ukraine's strikes on the Crimean bridge and will respond in a way 'much more painful' than the damage, per Interfax. Ukraine says Neptune missiles hit the rail section overnight on 19 November, the third strike in a week.
Prateek Rawat4 min
Severe Cyclonic Storm Akvan is expected to cross the coast near Gopalpur, Odisha, around noon on 20 November with winds of 90 to 100 km/h gusting to 110 km/h. Evacuation counts have risen from 47,000 to more than 1.2 lakh, a headline says 3 lakh, and dozens of trains are cancelled.
Amita Sahani4 min
Iran's IRGC Navy said on 19 November that two supertankers with over four million barrels each hit mines in the Strait of Hormuz and are burning. There is no independent confirmation. The IEA calls the Hormuz crisis the largest energy-security threat it has seen.
Reyaansh Agarawal4 min